Teaching Reactions How to Navigate

New topographical map shows the energy hills and valleys involved in turning electrons into fuel

(November 2015)

The reaction is often written quite simply. It is like writing, I'll drive from Washington, DC, to Albuquerque. The reality is far more complex. What route? How long will it take? How much will it cost? How much fuel (energy) will it take? In the case of creating hydrogen fuel from renewable energy sources, numerous options exist. Image: Nathan Johnson
Enlarge Image.

When starting out on a new adventure, it helps to have a map, allowing you to determine how to best spend your time and energy at each step along the way. For chemical reactions, the same is true. Without understanding the steps involved, reactions can end up on energy-wasting backroads or creating toxic wastes. Unfortunately, few reaction maps exist because of the expertise needed to chart all the possible paths. At Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, scientists mapped the reaction that turns wind-generated electricity into fuel and the amount of energy needed for each step.

It took three years and three supercomputers. "It was an outrageous amount of work," said Dr. Simone Raugei, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, who led the research.

The editors at ACS Catalysis selected it for the distinction of American Chemical Society Editors' Choice, making the article widely available.

Why It Matters: Energy from wind and solar stations is typically a use-or-lose proposition. Although some storage options exist, what if the energy could be turned into hydrogen or another fuel and used when it was needed? The challenges are the same as with most journeys: speed and efficiency. By mapping all the possible steps from electrons and protons to hydrogen fuel, scientists can fine-tune the catalyst and conditions to force the reaction through the best route. This work is a vital step for wind and solar energy to play a larger role in the energy landscape.

Methods: The team targeted the reaction that turns two protons and two electrons into a molecule of hydrogen with the help of the catalysts developed at PNNL in the Center for Molecular Electrocatalysis. The scientists avoided simple, perfect reaction systems and went for realistic environments. They considered -- at an atomistic level -- the catalyst, solvent, and all of the intermediates in the process. Intermediates are chemicals formed during the reaction that are then transformed again, leading to the final product. Intermediates are the way-stations on the map.

The complexity of the reactions involved an intense series of calculations that soaked up millions of hours on supercomputers at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, EMSL, and National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center. "The work was only possible through access to supercomputers, which was made possible by DOE," said Dr. Roger Rousseau, who conducts extensive modeling work at PNNL.

The result was a thermodynamic and kinetic map that showed all of the possible routes, intermediates, and energy necessary to complete each step. They then confirmed the mathematical results by conducting a host of detailed experiments, looking at the energy involved in the different steps.

Now, scientists are using the map to determine if they can modify the availability of protons, heat, solvent, or other conditions to speed the reaction along the fastest, most efficient route. Using the map, they've already found one path to avoid. Under certain circumstances, the reaction follows a series of turns, forming one intermediate and then the next, until it lands on a highly stable intermediate that requires an immense amount of energy to move on to the next step. This step is like being trapped in a little valley with the only way out being up a steep hill, an escape route the reaction rarely takes.

This work was done at the Center for Molecular Electrocatalysis, an Energy Frontier Research Center, or EFRC, funded by the DOE Office of Science's Basic Energy Sciences Office. "It was made possible through dedicated efforts from the computational scientists who worked closely with experimental chemists in our Center," said Dr. Morris Bullock, who worked on the study and directs the center.

What's Next? The team is using the map to determine the speed limit for hydrogen creation. Just how fast can hydrogen be produced? And how much energy would it cost? They also outlined a possible procedure to extend the approach used to map other catalyzed reactions, such as those involved in fuel cells, which break apart hydrogen to release the electrons to do work.

Acknowledgments

Sponsor: This research was supported as part of the Center for Molecular Electrocatalysis, an Energy Frontier Research Center funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences.

Research Area: Chemical Sciences

User Facilities: EMSL, National Energy Research Computing Center, and Oak Ridge National Laboratory

Research Team: Ming-Hsun Ho, Roger Rousseau, Eric S. Wiedner, Michel Dupuis, Daniel L. DuBois, R. Morris Bullock, and Simone Raugei, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory; John A. S. Roberts was with PNNL and is now with REC Silicon

Reference: MH Ho, R Rousseau, JAS Roberts, ES Wiedner, M Dupuis, DL DuBois, RM Bullock, and S Raugei. 2015. "Ab Initio-Based Kinetic Modeling for the Design of Molecular Catalysts: The Case of H₂ Production Electrocatalysts." ACS Catalysis 5(9):5436-5452. DOI: 10.1021/acscatal.5b01152

Related Highlight: Predicting Potholes on the Road to Renewable Energy http://www.pnl.gov/science/highlights/highlight.asp?id=2670